

I do believe rotating term limits is a good thing for the Supreme Court. For simplicity’s sake, make it 1 new justice every 2 years. Assuming the rest of the process remains the same around nominating and approving (though I wouldn’t be opposed to changes there either), it would allow 1 justice to be nominated by a president after assuming office and 1 justice to be nominated after a midterm shakeup of congress. If a president wins 2 terms, they would still not be able to nominate a majority of the court during their tenure in office (assuming the count remains at 9).
A supreme court justice would then get a total term length of 18 years in the position before their time is up, which is a reasonably long amount of time to be considered a career (essentially 1 full generation). You wouldn’t even really need to worry about imposing a strict limit of 1 term because most would age out (i.e. just be considered too old for re-nomination) or likely would not be re-nominated in favor of better candidates by whoever holds the oval office after 18 years.
Start cycling out the current justices in order of seniority, so Thomas goes in 2028 and then Roberts in 2030. In the (now much less likely) event a justice dies during their term, an interim appointment serves out the rest of their term but otherwise doesn’t shuffle the term length of everyone else.
I don’t think this would be a perfect system, but it would go a long way to address a number of issues that exist in the current court structure without having to change too much of the surrounding practices.
Agreed. I would prefer more extensive reform personally, because I believe there is a lot more that can be done to address the systemic flaws inherent to a position whereby political entities (the president, congress) dictate who is admitted to an office that was originally envisioned to be apolitical.
The 18-year term proposal is more of a bandaid fix, addressing a few of the major issues while minimizing friction with the current governmental structure in the US. It does absolutely nothing to address the fact that the court remains politicized, but if the court is already politicized and compromised, may as well start with fixing the balance of power that has allowed a single president to skew politics in his favor indefinitely until his appointees start dying. The more corrupt court we have today is otherwise just going to legislate from the bench and rule all attempts for reform unconstitutional.