• 0 Posts
  • 9 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 12th, 2023

help-circle


  • In only half jest, I think if you know enough about voting systems to have an opinion on voting systems, and especially if you can cite Condorcet, you’re ineligible to comment on best voting system.

    Remember, taking horse dewormer as an antiviral unironically caught on; in 2026 a real chunk of the voting populace thinks Trump is smart, and fucking measles is back. I once had an elementary school teacher ask me if crickets were baby bats, and I’ve heard more than once an adult “correct” a child that invertebrates weren’t animals.

    You need, if not the buy-in, at least not the skepticism of action of a voting system from these people.

    People get “1,2,3”. You can explain it because it’s not very different than a To-Do list.

    Anything more complicated than that is too complicated unless they’ve already been living with IRV enough to internalize it (and maybe not even then). STAR voting? Giving points away? Totals don’t just fail to add up evenly across the board but swing largely? Instant no-go.

    It’s like Linux folks that can’t realize the most complicated action in an OS to get 99.999% of things running under default settings is “double click the icon”.

    Or, if you prefer, because there’s an XKCD for everything: https://xkcd.com/2501/