• 0 Posts
  • 7 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: June 23rd, 2025

help-circle
  • Maybe my argument was oversimplifying. What I wanted to say is that Nextcloud alone does not provide a platform to fulfill the needs of a school (Teachers, kids and parents included) but it requires a lot more.

    Using Nextcloud as a starting point is imho the wrong approach. Nextcloud should be used as a part of a bigger solution that actually tries to create/provide a solution for schools. Nextcloud should be tightly integrated into that overall solution.

    And you are absolutely right: it solves the problem of sharing **homework material **. Bit this is its job: sharing files. Nothing more.


  • Having Nextcloud does not fulfill the actual needs of a school:

    • timetables/class schedules
    • provide information about homework
    • possibility to inform school that a child is sick
    • grades for the kid
    • chat platform per class and between kids, teachers and parents

    Nextcloud is for filesharing. But filesharing is not a priority need for a school. Yes, you can try to solve this via plugins and stuff. Bit this is just trying to bend something into shape that is not meant for the job.

    Better to use a different platform actually tailored to the use case. For example edupage. But edupage has lots to improve (e.g. using in in the browser on mobile is horrible and the UI is very cluttered).

    So I don’t see how this actually benefits a school.



  • How do you handle things like

    • custom domains
    • federation with an identity provider of the customer
    • customization for look and feel and technical (limitations for repo sizes etc.)
    • how do you handle connections to customer internal systems like artifactory, wiki, issue tracker, jira, etc.

    I could not find an information about that on your site.

    Working in a large corporation and also having worked on SaaS solutions these are important topics. Without even some rudimentary Information about that I wouldn’t even consider your service.

    Code hosting is the easy part. Propperer Integration eithwith external systems and separating customer data is the hard part.