• 0 Posts
  • 15 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: July 16th, 2023

help-circle
  • I’m curious how this “statutory duty to freedom of speech” works, considering this is someone spewing racist pseudoscience (if it even reaches the level of pseudoscience). They’ve also been suspended from academic institutions multiple times. And “may” have caused the suicide of another academic.

    Even ignoring the duty of care to students and the “inclusive, welcoming environment” commitment they allege they have… What value is there in debating obviously wrong ideas?

    If some professor firmly believed gravity isn’t real and the Earth is flat, would that be worth hearing out in an academic context? What value is that to students? “Here’s how you debate someone with ingrained ignorance/stupidity”? There are plenty of other ways to do that - use recordings, role play, go out to a (free) event of theirs.

    And I’ve even charitably assumed this is an event where some debate will take place…



  • I don’t want to put words in their mouth or explain away what they said, so I will quote Wikipedia:

    They said that their reference to the demonisation of rape concerned stereotypes surrounding perpetrators, arguing that rapists did not necessarily conform to a particular image and that such stereotypes could prevent victims from being believed, going on to explain that their reference to a spectrum concerned what they regarded as narrow legal and societal definitions of rape and sexual violence.

    Which is based on a Telegraph article:

    “The point I made about demonisation was that not all rapists fit a stereotype, and that all kinds of men can and do commit it.

    “The vast majority of sexual violence is from men who the victims know personally. Victims should be believed regardless of who the perpetrator was, and rapists should be punished in the strongest terms.

    “When talking about a spectrum I was making the point that laws often take a narrow definition of what rape and sexual violence is, which often allows it to continue without consequence. A full viewing of the interview clarifies this.

    “In a country where rape has the lowest conviction rates of any crime, and reoffending continues, this is an urgent and important conversation we need to have in Scotland. Any suggestion that my statements minimise or excuse rape or sexual assault are deeply false and misleading.”

    My personal impression would be this is getting at things like marital rape, but it’s not clarified further here, and I don’t have time to watch a full interview.

    At face value though, all I get from this is they didn’t mean anything malicious and they are definitely not a rape apologist, which is what a lot of the discourse around the topic seems to suggest.

    As a side note: they are non-binary and use they/them pronouns.



  • The Edinburgh-based former writer and academic said there was a “myth of the monster rapist” and “a demonisation of rape in the sense of it is a spectrum”.

    They continued: “It is a spectrum, none of which is any less or worse, but it is a spectrum of things that constitute one homogenised word ‘rape’”.

    Manivannan went on to argue that the idea of a rapist as a “big burly man” was understandably a source of fear.

    But the MSP told Rajasekaran that “any individual is capable of rape, including yourself and me, and I think that scary thought is the hardest to contend with”.

    Source: BBC

    Delicate topic that requires more careful wording, but to me it doesn’t sound like they were intending to downplay anything. That is also the claim made later during their apology.

    I wonder if John Cleese - who has in the past few years gone down the rabbit hole of becoming a pretty hardcore right-winger and JK Rowling/transphobe supporter, - might be a bit prejudiced against Manivannan. I also wonder why his recent history is not brought up in the article. Why is he even relevant to rector proceedings in a Scottish university?


  • Accuracy reached 75 per cent when considering the chatbot’s top three suggestions, while none of the conversations triggered safety stops.

    I mean I know doctors make mistakes too, but 75% if you get 3 guesses seems quite lacking. Especially if you then need to confirm with a doctor anyway.

    And yeah, the hallucination part is insane and surely unacceptable.

    Not to mention I’d need to read the study but I wonder what the cases and symptoms were, and if doctors ended up agreeing with the top 3 due to having read the transcripts beforehand. And we also know even experts can be fooled into thinking someone else is an expert if they talk well (see: Dr Fox effect, and related studies).


  • Man, I’m quite entertained here. Didn’t even address the main points of my reply.

    But yes, your own source states he did not profit from them. It’s unclear, but the implication seems to be that information comes from the records and not Ali’s own claims. In which case, yeah, there are some severe issues with tax evasion if you’re correct and he’s actually profiting lmao.

    You still haven’t said what my takeaway from this should be either. Representation of different views is good, and is often why the US has a VP from a different slant of the party than the President. Seems like that’d be fine within a British party too.

    Anyway, I agree with one point: this discussion has gone on too long without actually getting anywhere. I’m sure we’ll re-read this under another post some other day, and maybe actually end up gaining some sort of understanding from each other.


  • I still don’t get what your angle is here. All I get from this at best is they might not be perfect or monolithic. I don’t see why either case would be a deal-breaker. Those would be unreasonable expectations. And so I don’t care.

    But okay, let me address the specific point you’re making. I’ll even make a concession: let’s say they were letting for profit and living purely as a landlord (patently false, even from just your quotes): what matters from a leader and representative is that they can put their own interests aside and work for the wants and needs of the people they represent. And I see no reason as of yet to say they wouldn’t be able to do that. They could be completely ready to give up their property. If not, then it’s a problem and needs to be addressed, but that’s not an issue at present.




  • Privileged or not they’re still kids who are ending up with mental health problems due to the actions of their school. You can still have empathy for children despite where they happened to be born and what choices their parents made for them.

    Not to mention the article is clearly stating this situation is happening outside of Eton with the more general child population with no recourse. Unfortunately, we currently live in a situation where wealthy and influential parents are the ones who can get psychologists and journalists to take note of problems, but that is not the fault of 13 year olds.





  • Oh yeah, we definitely want to be buddies with Russia. Fuck off with that. Won’t address that any further.

    Moving past that: lots of things you could say about the Greens, but they’ve been vocal about their ideals and are seemingly committed. That includes being pro-Palestine and trying to help the working class and other minorities. Now that might change in the realities of governance, but writing them off as equivalent to Labour is pessimistic to an unwarranted degree.