Send me bad puns. Good puns welcome too. America delenda est.

  • 0 Posts
  • 338 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 13th, 2024

help-circle







  • “Is my target future still viable at all?” Is the generalized decision, it is binary, and it is hard.

    Not really, it’s a continuum from “not at all” to “undeniably yes.” The number of meaningfully different potential answers is literally infinite. It’s only binary if you round up or down, and then you immediately have to decide your threshold for rounding. Which is to say: Even your hyper-generalized model still requires implicit assumptions to produce anything resembling a binary choice, because the world is more complicated than that.

    So your three assumptions don’t relate to this model at all. It makes no claim about the immutability of politicians. There is no carve out for elections. There is no general prescription for what a politician should prioritize.

    But your model also can’t on its own produce a “vote blue no matter who and don’t protest genocide” conclusion, or for that matter any concrete conclusion about what do actually do; you need more assumptions to tie it into politics in a more concrete way.



  • I know the barbarians adopted a lot of Roman culture; I’m just calling them barbarians because it’s easier than saying “non-state peoples on Rome’s frontiers.” Also if I gave the impression Rome’s legions were uniquely “civilized” then let me correct that: Everybody raped and pillaged in those times; it’s just that from the perspective of someone living in Roman lands the rape and pillaging that happened when Rome lost is going to be more relevant. I don’t know about Oedoacer per se, but for instance Rome did get sacked a lot in those times and sacking is just rape and pillaging when it happens in a city. In the pre-modern world, just about the only thing worse than an army marching over you was one successfully marching at you; nothing here is uniquely barbarian.




  • The answer is always to choose the lesser of two evils if you’re faced with a binary choice (and the reality is that often things are binary choices).

    Before I explain myself: I strongly disagree; it’s almost never the case that a choice is truly binary. That requires that, from the nearly infinite potential choices available, only two are viable enough to be considered. Not three, not one, two. Statistically that doesn’t make sense; binary choices are usually the result of imposing either very broad categories or very narrow assumptions. In the case of electoral politics, the assumptions are that:

    1- It’s impossible to coerce candidates to change before they’re elected (it’s impossible to choose between multiple potential Harrises).

    2- The only result of an election worth thinking about is who wins (it’s impossible to make an electoral choice whose desired results are unrelated to the next guy).

    3- Politics can or should prioritize elections over other avenues for progress (it’s impossible to work outside the electoral cycle).

    There’s a reason almost no successful protest/resistance movement worked that way. The total rejection of long-term strategy (edit:) would be fatal to any serious movement for social change, which is how you know this isn’t a serious movement for social change.

    But like, this is an entirely new choice.

    My point is that the mental framework that the vote blue no matter who crowd were working with is going to (try to) prevent effective resistance to a Democratic but centrist-dominated Congress. The same rhetoric seen in 2024 is going to be mobilized against, say, anti-Jeffries or pro-impeachment protests. Pro-Palestinian protests are the latest attempt at not taking a nap when the lesser evil is in charge and they were smothered to death by not only moderates but also self-proclaimed progressives.



  • I mean what timeframe are you working with here? In any case here’s a good read on what the fall of Rome in the West would’ve actually looked like. Relevant excerpt:

    Living standards thus declined back down to the pre-Roman Iron Age norm while at the same time the carrying capacity of the empire also declined down to that norm, leading to what must have been decades of brutal misery as food ran short, malnourished infants died before their time, cities shrank and the world grew poor.

    And that’s aside from all the raping and pillaging that happened whenever Rome lost, which was increasingly often leading up to its fall (again in the West).


  • They absolutely did notice, because the legions weren’t sitting around twiddling their thumbs before going away; they were fighting the various barbarians. When the legions left, the barbarians rolled in and that was pretty bad, to put it lightly. Not to make it seem like the Romans were innocent defenders of civilization, but when an invading army rolls into a conquered/raided territory in this period they rape and pillage everything that isn’t nailed down, and of course it’s no fun to have your city sieged or sacked. The loss of trade (since the Roman state wasn’t there to crack down on banditry and piracy) also reduced the complexity and prosperity of the Roman economy, leading to population decline that wouldn’t be made up for centuries. Here’s a good read on the topic by a Roman historian, but the short of it is that it would’ve absolutely sucked to live anywhere in the Roman Empire within a century before or after its fall in the West. Here’s a relevant quote:

    Living standards thus declined back down to the pre-Roman Iron Age norm while at the same time the carrying capacity of the empire also declined down to that norm, leading to what must have been decades of brutal misery as food ran short, malnourished infants died before their time, cities shrank and the world grew poor.


  • Well seemingly the plan was to force her to capitulate before she lost; Uncommitted for example kept saying this over and over again but were only subjected to cannibalism by their supposed allies. A united progressive front might’ve gotten it into her thick Zionist head that maybe full-on Zionism was a bad idea (or hell, with enough disruption even forced immediate action; there’s more to resistance than elections). Besides, even if we accept the premise that Harris would’ve lost even harder rather than change course, a principled progressive stance against genocide would’ve sent a signal that Democrats can’t win while backing genocide. Instead we got the worst of both worlds, where the genocide continues unabated, Harris just barely loses and the lesson learned is that progressives can’t take a stand for shit. And even setting aside all that, the cannibalism that happened over the course of 2024 was a net negative to the world all on its own. I remember the vote blue no matter who crowd complaining that the people who might well have been watching their friends and family die for over a year wouldn’t vote for the murderers. We should all remember the people who were—who are—denying that a genocide was even happening because the right party was in charge. Ugh, this disgusts me to even think about. A world where so-called progressives didn’t engage in genocide apologia and victim blaming would’ve been a better one all on its own.