• 0 Posts
  • 136 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: October 16th, 2025

help-circle












  • I saw a lot of articles about this as the trial was ongoing - more than for most ongoing trials. I don’t know if the reporting rules were different or what, but I really didn’t want to read about it until the trial was over. I don’t really know why, but I think partly I knew I didn’t want to read about a rape trial every single day and so I would only get a partial view of things at that level of detail. I’d rather have the court do the summarising for me by handing down a verdict and then read at the conclusion.

    Now that’s happened, I’m glad justice has been served. It’s always mixed feelings with these trials: it turns out another public figure was a scumbag, but at least another scumbag is going to be punished. Hopefully the publicity leads to a sense that these crimes are unacceptable and will be punished.





  • The Naqba was genocidal. But most states have some kind of horror in their past that is not condoned by their ongoing existence. The USA’s existence does not condone the ethnic cleansing of native Americans. England’s existence does not condone the Harrying of the North. France’s existence does not condone the Terror. This is just not how “condoning” works. And even if it were, human rights are more important, and the right to self-determination exists for the Israelis who are now, like it or not, in Israel. Just as Israeli Jews cannot be trusted with power over Palestinians, Palestinian Arabs cannot be trusted with power over Israelis - either situation (one of which we are seeing) results in intolerable ethnic cleansing.

    I know it is horrible and feels racist and like it’s letting a crime go unpunished to have Israel continue to exist despite the Naqba. But the only way to avoid that is to just do another genocide against Israeli Jews. That’s not justifiable. Putting one of those other aspects before the necessity to protect a population against new war crimes is, as I said, unhelpful. By all means focus on the other population that needs protecting, and which is not being protected, but that’s not what this is.




  • So, you think that a racist policy can be rational when the purpose is to preserve peace, it seems. I think this is more or less what I’m getting at in the case of Zionism.

    Of course there were a range of intentions, then as now, which the label of Zionism encompasses, ranging up to “emigrate and overthrow” then (stay here and genocide, now) but including “emigrate and coexist.” (a peaceful two-state solution with full rights for Israeli Arabs and for Palestinians) I certainly take issue with the former, but the idea of wanting to migrate somewhere for a better life, somewhere perhaps you feel a historical connection to and where many people like you already live, and to participate in a democratic process there, is quite acceptable to me and I think can be properly called Zionism too.