• 0 Posts
  • 11 Comments
Joined 9 months ago
cake
Cake day: February 12th, 2026

help-circle




  • I never claimed it was alive. I do think you oversimplify it’s function, though.

    Let me provide an example, and you tell me where the misunderstanding exists?

    I take a photo of a wall, and tell a model I’d like a recommendation on color to match the existing palette. It responds with a recommendation that won’t clash, but further adds that based on the furniture in the room it suspects the room is used for studying and contemplation. Based on this unprompted observation, it recommends a different specific color, and further adds that the distance to the ceiling is less than standard, so it further recommends incorporating vertical lines into the design to provide the illusion of greater space than is actually available.

    I call the additional information insightful, and surmising the purpose of the room based on furnishings, when it was unrelated to the original question, is an example of advanced inference of information. Is it not?




  • I value your time and response, but it doesn’t match my experience. I am a computer scientist, and have created neutral networks. Just because they aren’t structured the same, and have different methodologies, doesn’t mean the similarities end at visual representation. The layered digital neurons allow obfuscation of actual processing, there is no hard coded logic as you seem to imply.

    And I don’t know what models you’ve been using, but I get a valid, relevant and insightful response 99% of the time, not once every million attempts. Your assertions do not align with my experiences at all.

    Generating something that did not exist before IS creation, and it can be innovative. I don’t know how you can assert otherwise, unless you’ve been using very poor excuses for LLMs. I don’t see trial and error in responses to my prompts,I see thoughtful, intuitive and insightful responses that demonstrate a level of context inference that couldn’t just be random chance.

    Perhaps you’re familiar with the structural, mathematical and organizational concepts, and you can differentiate their respective methods of operation, but it seems to me like you have faulty information regarding capabilities and the resulting potential usage of LLM models.

    Would you be willing to give me examples of things you’ve attempted that didn’t work until after millions of tries, and which model(s) you were using? You seem confident, so I’m wondering where the mismatch is in our mutually shared, individually observed reality.