• 0 Posts
  • 10 Comments
Joined 4 years ago
cake
Cake day: September 15th, 2022

help-circle
  • Aria@lemmygrad.mltoUnited Kingdom@feddit.uk•No politik here
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    2
    ·
    27 days ago

    You’re right, there isn’t enough information in the image itself to disprove your proposal. There isn’t even a date. But given the geopolitical circumstance and the official character of the post, an implication of geopolitical motivation can be interpreted. Let me try to find some way to measure if the implication was felt by the audience.

    Hm.

    Perhaps if the audience unprompted connected the image to Russia? Aha! Yes, okay, so that would make a good piece of evidence to look for. In this case, our only audience is you. Did you link it to Russia? Actually, yes you did. You linked an article about Russia and the war in Ukraine.

    Now we know that even if this was not planned as an act of indoctrination, the propaganda effect remains. 100% of our surveyed audience members linked the event to Russia.


  • Aria@lemmygrad.mltoUnited Kingdom@feddit.uk•No politik here
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    4
    ·
    27 days ago

    The picture is showing a classroom, which is part of a school. The small people in the front are children. They’re all wearing school uniforms. Using advanced, human-level pattern-matching in our reasoning, we can make a guess that the children in the picture are attending the school as students.

    What is being pointed out is that Bridget Phillipson took part in “making protests and statements about geopolitical events” herself, though in support of the UK’s current foreign policy. Lucy Powell is now saying that is inappropriate, which means her office has done something inappropriate without acknowledgement or comment.

    What is being insinuated by pointing this out is that they don’t actually think it’s inappropriate, but they want to limit “making protests and statements about geopolitical events” to those that support the UK’s current foreign policy.

    Rather than being interested in educating students, she’s interested in brainwashing students.

    One hopes that the education system will try to give students tools to question and verify narratives, and live life with principles derived from dialectic analysis. But since that is proven false by the image, if you try to reason about this inconsistency or hypocrisy, then the likely conclusion you will draw is that Lucy Powell’s goal instead seems to be to create ignorant stormtroopers that will obediently carry out her genocides.

    Hope this helps.


  • I’m curious: what would you need to see from a product like this before you’d trust it with your code?

    I’d probably take you (or any given service) at your word, but you need to actually advertise the advantages. Of course it’s risky, it’s easy to be heavy-handed or to signal your position in a way that dissuades someone. But if you don’t properly name the fears, I have no reason to think you’re addressing the fears either.

    Because you’re one person I trust your intention now, but that isn’t a good angle either, because now I wouldn’t trust your longevity and procedures for dealing with disasters (paying for availability after the business venture has failed so customers can download their data for a few months after sunset, money to deal with cyber attacks, stuff like that).

    The biggest seal of quality thing that’s possible for you to get with your current angle is to get a government (even just a city or province) customer and saying you’re trusted by them, or getting some sort of official commission to develop for the public sector. Then the customer would feel safe the funding is intended to achieve the stated goals. But you can’t will those contracts into existence either.


  • Any level of extra sovereignty makes a big difference for big customers, so the answer is yes. But for individual developers and start-ups, it’ll come down to if your owners have stock in USA/Israeli companies.

    If they do then there is no sovereignty. Rewarding a capitalist who happens to have an EU member passport is still rewarding an USA capitalist. There’s no difference and other than with the odd nationalistic one, all of them will primarily have loyalty towards the USA regardless of on-paper nationality. It’s simply the pragmatic choice when you are a capitalist.

    And so any reason to be scared of hosting in the USA will still apply. You’ll still over-comply, rat us out, censor us, invite USA-competitors to study our private repos. And it’ll be based on the exact same cheap orders from the USA, and you’ll still ignore our national laws with as little care as a Microsoft, Google, or indeed as a SAP.

    Without sovereignty, what you’re doing is just using nationalism to market a product. We all know putting the USA flag on a product in the USA works great. Used to not work as good in Europe, but now make that an EU flag and it doesn’t feel nationalistic, so it works. But the reason it doesn’t feel nationalistic is because the implication is that it’s sovereign. People will catch on that it isn’t very soon.

    Depending on how strict you want to be, you might also need to disallow USA puppets like the Gulf countries and the UK from your owner’s portfolios. And a lot of others are going to be upset to see Russia or China on there too.



  • The BBC wrote a story that hurt them

    The BBC’s editorial line is that humans are worthless, and that genocide is forgivable.

    Reporting did not reinforce their world view

    Any decent human should share the world view that genocide is a pressing matter.

    They expected the BBC to be perfect and inevitable failures to meet that standard lead to disappointment

    No one expects it to be perfect, but failure to meet expected standards means it’s unworthy of existing.

    They found the style of reporting annoying

    It’s laughable that you can use words like “annoying” when defending an organisation championing for genocide. Their reporting isn’t annoying, it’s psychopathic and sickening.

    Perhaps some reporters were annoying

    Criminals. Enemies of mankind. Monsters. Some of their reporters are monsters.

    A cynic might think that something deeper is going on, for example, a systematic campaign to erode trust in the BBC.

    Perhaps this is a natural and uncoordinated response to the BBCs systematic campaign to make people value some human lives over others?

    For me it, with all its failings, is one of the best public broadcasting organisations in the world.

    I take it you regularly come across reporting from the others and find them wanting?