• 0 Posts
  • 36 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: October 26th, 2025

help-circle
  • You still haven’t explained why being a foreign head of state is any different than having a job in the US. Your point was their devotion, but so what?

    Is your concern that their vote reflects their political beliefs? That’s silly, don’t you think? Of course it reflects their political beliefs.

    Is your concern that their political beliefs may reasonably be aligned with the destruction of the US? That’s a bit far fetched, don’t you think?

    But regardless, he’s an American. If he wants to destroy the state, shouldn’t he be free to vote that way?

    Or, are you concerned that, by acting as head of state, his actions would arguable be that of the state he represents? Meaning… it’s not Leo XIV voting, it’s the Pope?

    You don’t make that same conclusion when the president votes, do you?

    Should Trump not be allowed to vote because he’s the head of MAGA? Surely MAGA is worse than Pope, right?

    I’m really struggling to find the coherency in your perspective. Can you help me out?





  • That’s exactly the distinction I’m asking about. Algebra and coordinate geometry can represent supply and demand, and they can prove what follows if the model’s assumptions hold. They do not prove that the model accurately describes an actual economy.

    For example, from assumed supply and demand functions, you can mathematically prove where their curves intersect. But mathematics alone cannot prove that real consumers have that demand curve, that real producers have that supply curve, that the relevant variables were held constant, or that the resulting equilibrium is what caused the observed market price.

    “Price rises when demand increases, ceteris paribus” is a model-derived prediction. Whether real markets actually behave that way, under what conditions, and how accurately… all of that is empirical questions. Data can support, falsify, estimate, or justify the model’s applicability but the algebra cannot prove its correspondence to reality.

    This is in stark contrast to physics. It makes economics look more like theology. Although, that’s probably still a loaded statement.

    Regardless, “nearly every concept in Econ 101 has a mathematical breakdown” doesn’t answer my question. I’m specifically asking for an example where the mathematics proves that the mathematical model itself is an accurate description of the real economy, rather than merely proving consequences within the model.

    And if the answer is that economics establishes that correspondence empirically rather than mathematically, then that’s precisely the distinction I was making.





  • Yeah that’s how this stuff seems to work. For some reason it’s really difficult for decentralized protest to scale its efforts in match of the scaled sophistication of their oppressors. Rather than protest getting more sophisticated, we just hope the protest gets bigger.

    But honestly feel like a clear path through this would be to match their sophistication. Meaning, we need hactivist entities that specialize in hiding their identities, making public disclosures, and backing up their claims with actions.

    The guy leaking the GTA6 material? He’s on the right track. We need more of that across various sectors.

    I would argue it should work similarly to why the US struggles capitulating Iran — their guard is decentralized. They don’t need instruction from the top to carry out support.



  • It should be. But that’s not how western nations handle political crimes, it would seem.

    I’d probably support a future where the ICC can impeach a sitting president, along with another capacity somewhere for foreign states to remove our sitting president.

    I’d like to see a stronger ability to sanction companies, too. Not just the people in the company, but the company itself. Like limiting the volume of power that a data center can consume, if it acts in bad faith.


  • It’s not that corporations are inherently evil. It’s that profit optimizing algorithms are inherently non-empathetic. These companies are basically algorithms, in the same way that a computer is basically a calculator (bad analogy, I know).

    Every company has a value stream in which capital is produced through labor. The working components are the protocols, the procedure is the algorithm. The algorithm gets optimized by C-suite for the benefit of stakeholders. Benefit, meaning profit.

    We’ve always known that corporation interests only sometimes align with social interests, because there’s a difference. Socially, you want a good life. Corporations want good profit. Sometimes having good profit means capitulating to society, but most often it actually doesn’t.

    I’d like to see more worker owned businesses. The problem is that we don’t really have a culture where groups of people come together in order to form democratically run worker collectives. How can we build this culture?

    If we could build that culture, I’d favor worker collectives over traditional corps any day of the week. It would fit into my mind much like preferring open source over SaaS.

    I want to see groups of people with entrepreneurial spirits that get excited about the idea of building a worker collective to compete in the various sectors of the economy. We could create a “hit list,” containing some of the most shitty companies that we’d like to displace. We can target them while prioritizing collectives to produce.




  • A good approach might be to target sectors. Easier to manage, being smaller, and it could still have a heavy impact if you’re strategic about it.

    Also, needs to be decentralized in my opinion. Take a look at why the US is having such a hard time with Iran — their military leadership is decentralized. The pros are that you can’t decapitate the leadership, but the cons are that you can’t unilaterally make a decision to change course very fast.

    We need that. Kick off a decentralized general strike, so that everyone and their moms feel vindicated and empowered in striking. No grand “start here” and “end there” dates. Maybe it’s just “see how much time you can take off in November,” followed by “try to take more off in December.” The government would be fighting a cultural battle here, not a legal one. It’s pretty good at legal battles, but not the other.

    This obviously creates several issues. People need money for food, housing, medical, … as such, there should be solutions for these concerns readily available. Food banks, hospitals that won’t turn you down, … how are you going to make a society feel like risking their immediate home is something they can do? It took a pandemic to make people not work nor pay rent last time, but that was much less of a choice than this would be.