- 0 Posts
- 40 Comments
couldhavebeenyou@lemmy.zipto
politics @lemmy.world•Abdul El-Sayed stands up for trans people & their rights in "hostile" 60 Minutes interview - LGBTQ Nation
330·16 days ago(and their parents if they are a minor)
Some people would say he’s murdering trans kids with this little footnote
couldhavebeenyou@lemmy.zipto
politics @lemmy.world•Donald Trump and Jeffrey Epstein Allegedly 'Argued Over Who Would Take 13-Year-Old Girl's Virginity,' Per Explosive House Report
1·20 days agoWhat if you get accused in such a way?
couldhavebeenyou@lemmy.zipto
politics @lemmy.world•Vivek Ramaswamy Pulls His Disturbing Ad After ‘Our Numbers Cratered’
121·20 days agoDon’t you worry! They’ll have forgotten all about this come next election cycle
couldhavebeenyou@lemmy.zipto
politics @lemmy.world•Donald Trump and Jeffrey Epstein Allegedly 'Argued Over Who Would Take 13-Year-Old Girl's Virginity,' Per Explosive House Report
12·21 days agoRoutinely? With things like this?
couldhavebeenyou@lemmy.zipto
politics @lemmy.world•Donald Trump and Jeffrey Epstein Allegedly 'Argued Over Who Would Take 13-Year-Old Girl's Virginity,' Per Explosive House Report
14·21 days agoI wouldn’t really call this ‘evidence’
couldhavebeenyou@lemmy.zipto
politics @lemmy.world•Donald Trump and Jeffrey Epstein Allegedly 'Argued Over Who Would Take 13-Year-Old Girl's Virginity,' Per Explosive House Report
23·21 days agoThat reminds me of the crowd in /r/thedonald where they were all getting riled up they were going to round up all the pedos immediately if they won
couldhavebeenyou@lemmy.zipto
politics @lemmy.world•Donald Trump and Jeffrey Epstein Allegedly 'Argued Over Who Would Take 13-Year-Old Girl's Virginity,' Per Explosive House Report
211·21 days agoWhat if the candidate you support gets accused in such a way?
couldhavebeenyou@lemmy.zipto
politics @lemmy.world•Donald Trump and Jeffrey Epstein Allegedly 'Argued Over Who Would Take 13-Year-Old Girl's Virginity,' Per Explosive House Report
113·21 days agoWell it’s a tabloid writing about a ‘chilling accusation!’ about something 30 years ago
What would you do?
couldhavebeenyou@lemmy.zipto
politics @lemmy.world•DCCC Releases Its First Anti-Trans Ad, Supporting SC Democrat Nancy Lacore
11·24 days agoAnd how does this work for a trans girl that doesn’t take estrogen?
couldhavebeenyou@lemmy.zipto
politics @lemmy.world•DCCC Releases Its First Anti-Trans Ad, Supporting SC Democrat Nancy Lacore
12·25 days agoAre you implying that trans girls are the only ones who have hormones?
couldhavebeenyou@lemmy.zipto
politics @lemmy.world•DCCC Releases Its First Anti-Trans Ad, Supporting SC Democrat Nancy Lacore
13·25 days agoAnd sometimes at a serious advantage in a girl’s league. What’s the solution?
couldhavebeenyou@lemmy.zipto
politics @lemmy.world•DCCC Releases Its First Anti-Trans Ad, Supporting SC Democrat Nancy Lacore
13·26 days agoHere’s another nice sentence I read
In any context we would write off factors like muscle-to-weight ratio and muscle distribution as valuable, but not something worth subdividing a sport over.
couldhavebeenyou@lemmy.zipto
politics @lemmy.world•DCCC Releases Its First Anti-Trans Ad, Supporting SC Democrat Nancy Lacore
12·26 days agoDo you mean when they said “we divide by gender, not by any physiological characteristics”?
How is that a counter to this?
couldhavebeenyou@lemmy.zipto
politics @lemmy.world•DCCC Releases Its First Anti-Trans Ad, Supporting SC Democrat Nancy Lacore
15·26 days agoAh ok I am the one ignorant of the science. I am the one saying the science is too difficult and then chooses to “just separate by gender” because checks notes “that’s how it is”. Lol
Let’s use an easy example to see how this translates to the real world. Imagine you want to take up boxing.
So you’ve got the gear on. You learned the basics. You’re ready to start your first practice match against an actual opponent. You think physiology shouldn’t be taken into account.
Imagine you are a midget and they put you up against someone three times the weight.
Is it ok because it’s the same gender?
couldhavebeenyou@lemmy.zipto
politics @lemmy.world•DCCC Releases Its First Anti-Trans Ad, Supporting SC Democrat Nancy Lacore
17·26 days agoI have a feeling you’re trying to say that dividing by XY/XX is too broad of a brush (which is why you think the wingspan thing is a great counter argument). But, sadly, broad the brush must be. It’s impossible to organise 8 billion sports competitions where you only compete against your exact genetic equal, aka yourself. Not having a perfect solution doesn’t mean you should opt for a worse one.
Also we do sometimes decide that XY and XX can compete against each other. Interestingly enough, we do this in cases where the physiological differences are unimportant. In most sports, for example, they are lumped together when it’s more meaningful to create age groups, and only split up when differences caused by sex become too large.
The weird argument at the end shows exactly the inverse of what you think it does. I don’t have any problem ‘accepting’ that they are grouped by physiology, and sometimes not, after deciding on measures we find meaningful. In fact, it is you who cannot accept this.
We’re where we started: Deep down you understand that there are meaningful reasons to divide categories on scientific factors, but at the end you decide to brush all that away because you believe that ‘being pro-trans on all fronts’, with a big emphasis on all, is more important.
couldhavebeenyou@lemmy.zipto
politics @lemmy.world•DCCC Releases Its First Anti-Trans Ad, Supporting SC Democrat Nancy Lacore
15·27 days agothe reality today is that we still divide sports teams by gender
No we don’t. And I find it funny that your argument boils down to “that’s the rule, end of story” and accusing me of “trying to sound progressive”, lol. Maybe you need to think about what that means.
Your example is excellent to point out your mistake.
Phelps is in the top percentage, but there are swimmers with a bigger wingspan. He was a great swimmer, but he was still within range for his competitors. For example: at his peak in say 2008, he handily beat the swimmer in second place by less than 2% in the 200m. The winner in the women’s category, however, was 11,5% percent slower. Can you see the difference? The gold medal in the women’s category would not have even qualified for the olympics, if there hadn’t been a women’s caterory. Do you understand what that means for her?
Meanwhile, Phelps has been beaten, and had his records have been broken, by swimmers with a smaller wingspan.
Of course you could divide swimming categories by wingspan, but the reason they don’t do it is because they don’t feel it’s necessary to create a more meaningful competition. ‘They’ being the athletes and officials that cooperate to regulate the sport.
But that’s entirely different from combining athletes that just don’t stand a chance against eachother. For example, a ‘classic male’ boxer can punch around 100% harder and around 20% faster than a ‘classic female’ boxer with the same weight. Do you think it would be meaningful to put the two into the ring against eachother? What reason could you think of to do so?
couldhavebeenyou@lemmy.zipto
politics @lemmy.world•DCCC Releases Its First Anti-Trans Ad, Supporting SC Democrat Nancy Lacore
28·27 days agoYou’re forgetting about muscle-to-weight-ratio and muscle distribution, amongst others. I’m happy that you acknowledge that dividing by physiology is ‘the ideal outcome’. But then you just wipe everythingfrom the whiteboard and replace it with “make trans (women) happy”.
I, too, want to see trans women happy. But that doesn’t mean it automatically invalidates every other argument.
Chances are, a dem winning in a traditionally R county or state is not going to be the hardest socialist or progressive you can find. Best to suck it up and keep moving the window in the right direction